12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Winnipeg That Are Worth Crossing the City For
For me, pizza is the most balanced food out there. You’ve got the warm, chewy crabs from the crust, the gooey richness of melted cheese, savory chunks of meat, and the freshness of veggies all in one bite.
Lucky for us, Winnipeg is packed with spots that take pizza seriously, from cozy neighborhood joints to trendy wood-fired pizzerias. No matter what style you’re craving—thin crust, deep dish, Neapolitan, New York—Winnipeg has them all.
The only hard part is deciding where to start—but don’t worry, I’ve done the tasty legwork for you. Let me guide you to the top pizza spots in Winnipeg that’ll make you thank me for your next favorite slice.
Red Swan Pizza
– Media credit: redswanpizza_ca
Website: https://redswanpizza.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/redswanpizza_ca/
Address: 130 Osborne St
Hours: Mon – Thurs, Sun: 11 AM – 1 AM
Fri – Sat: 11 AM – 2 AM
Contact: (204) 306-4040
Must-Order: Spicy Paneer Pizza with Sesame Seed Crust
Red Swan Pizza is a women-owned pizza spot that’s a go-to for die-hard meat lovers and veggie enthusiasts alike.
You can build your pie on a traditional, thin, or regular gluten-free base, and opt for sauces that are dairy-free, too. But what they’re really known for is their luscious vegan cheese—plant-based eaters from across the city go here for this.
My favorite order is their Spicy Paneer Pizza with Sesame Seed Crust—something you won’t find at just any pizza joint. It’s a bold combo of warm spices and creamy paneer cheese that pairs perfectly with the nutty crunch of sesame seeds.
To grab a deal without breaking the bank, keep an eye out for their online promos, like their Mix and Match Deal. You can pick any two or more menu items alongside their pizza for only $10.95 each; imagine wings or pasta with your pie—yum!
| Pro Tip: Download Red Swan’s app for the smoothest ordering experience. You can quickly reorder your favorites, browse the menu, and most importantly, get notifications about the latest deals and exclusive promos! |
Vera Pizza
– Media credit: verapizza_
Website: https://www.yelp.ca/biz/vera-winnipeg
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/verapizza_
Address: 670 Osborne St
Hours: Wed – Sat: 5 PM – 10 PM
Contact: (204) 222-6306
Must-Order: Napoletana
Vera Pizza lives up to its name—vera meaning true in Italian—by staying true to the roots of authentic Neapolitan pizza. Inspired by the traditions of Naples, the birthplace of pizza, they bring the same rustic charm to the Peg.
What makes their pizzas so good is the dough, which is hand-stretched and cooked to perfection in just 90 seconds in their 537 °C oven. This results in a crust that’s blistered on the outside and chewy on the inside.
Their menu is proof that less is more—they offer Italian staples like Gaeta olives, spicy Calabrian salami, pancetta, and house fennel sausage. My go-to order is their Napoletana, topped with tomato sauce, garlic, oregano, capers, and anchovy.
Of course, pizza pairs best with a good drink. I recommend choosing from their all-Italian wine list—not a single bottle is priced over $42, which is pretty cool.
| Pro Tip: I always grab a spot on their charming streetside covered patio. With its wooden floors, fencing, and quirky tables and chairs, it’s the perfect place to people-watch while enjoying a Neapolitan slice and sipping wine. |
Wall Street Slice
– Media credit: y2kprairieprincess
Website: https://www.wallstreetslice.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/wallstreetslice
Address: 753 Wall St
Hours: Tue – Thurs: 11 AM – 8 PM
Friday: 11 AM – 9 PM
Saturday: 11 AM – 8:30 PM
Sunday: 3 PM – 8 PM
Contact: (204) 221-7272
Must-Order: New York Style
Wall Street Slice may be small and locally owned, but it packs a big punch when it comes to flavor and quality. They’re serious about sourcing ethically raised ingredients, and everything that comes out of the kitchen is made with care.
You can really taste the difference in their dough, which is cold-fermented for up to seven days to develop that perfect texture and depth of flavor. And for those avoiding gluten, they have a house-made, gluten-free crust made from almond flour.
As hinted at by their name, they’re experts in churning out New York-style pizza (my fave!)—the kind you fold in half, street-style. Sold by the slice or a massive 18” pie, this classic has a thin base with a thicker, airy crust edge that’s delightfully crispy.
Another crowd-pleaser is their Sicilian Square pizza (imagine focaccia turned into pizza). The dough rises to over an inch thick, creating a crunchy, golden crust on the outside and a soft, fluffy interior.
| Pro Tip: Wall Street Slice offers three catering packages, with the most popular being Package 1. This includes 4 huge NY-style slices, garlic rolls, fresh salads, and drinks for just $16.98 per person—plates, napkins, and cutlery are included. |
Freshslice Pizza
– Media credit: freshslice
Website: https://www.freshslice.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/freshslice/
Address: 500 Portage Ave #106
Hours: Mon – Wed: 10:30 AM – 12 AM
Thurs – Fri: 10:30 AM – 2 AM
Sunday: 11 AM – 12 AM
Contact: (431) 570-0329
Must-Order: Butter Chicken Pizza
Freshslice Pizza is known for fresh ingredients, signature multi-grain dough, and low-calorie sauces. Add in perfectly baked cheese, and you’ve got pizza that’s a little lighter than your usual slice, but just as tasty!
Their proprietary, multi-million-dollar dough system is designed to weaken gluten, making it easier to digest and gentler on the stomach. Plus, every batch of dough is made fresh in-house—no stale crusts here.
My top pick here is their luscious Butter Chicken Pizza. This fusion masterpiece includes creamy white garlic sauce, grilled chicken breast, red peppers, cheddar, and of course, butter chicken sauce.
What’s cool is their Create Your Own Pizza options. Simply pick a sauce, mozzarella cheese, and then go wild on extras—choose between a simple three-topping combo or go all out with unlimited toppings.
| Pro Tip: I recommend downloading their app and signing up for Freshslice Rewards. You’ll earn 5% cashback on every order and unlock personalized deals just for you. |
Parcel Pizza
– Media credit: parcelpizza
Website: https://www.parcelpizza.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/parcelpizza/
Address: 221-A Stradbrook Ave
Hours: Mon, Wed, Sun: 4:30 PM – 10:30 PM
Thursday: 11:30 AM – 2:30 PM, 4:30 PM – 10:30 PM
Fri – Sat:11:30 AM – 2:30 PM, 4:30 PM – 12 AM
Contact: (204) 421-6711
Must-Order: Spicy Dill Pickle Pizza
Parcel Pizza is known in the city for keeping things fresh, local, and seasonal. In fact, their menu celebrates the best of what’s produced close to home, from Berkshire pork bacon and house-made fennel sausage to regional cheeses and garden greens.
One of their most talked-about creations is their Spicy Dill Pickle Pizza, which I highly recommend. This vegetarian-friendly pie layers white sauce, Bothwell mozzarella, gorgonzola, fresh dill, and plenty of pickles, finished with Calabrian chili.
For an affordable pizza day, I always check out their combo deals. Imagine paying only $14 for two slices and a draft beer, or just $4.50 for their Feature Slice!
If you’re not into beer, they offer a cocktail list that pairs perfectly with their pies—try the Electric Squirrel, a mix of Tito’s lime leaf vodka, Midori melon liqueur, and kiwi puree. Basically, it’s summer in a glass that can cut through the richness of their pizza.
| Pro Tip: Don’t skip their awesome dips! Elevate your slice by choosing from chili oil, chili flakes, basic sauce, ranch, grated parm, and hot honey. |
Flying Pizza
– Media credit: flyingpizzawpg
Website: https://flyingpizzaorders.com
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/flyingpizzawpg/
Address: 400 Edison Ave
Hours: Mon – Thurs, Sun: 10 AM – 2 AM
Fri – Sat: 10 AM – 3 AM
Contact: (204) 940-7772
Must-Order: Butter Chicken Pizza
Flying Pizza is home to one of the biggest pies in Winnipeg, coming in at a massive 26 inches. That’s nearly a foot larger than the standard 16” or 18” pizzas you’ll find elsewhere—the ultimate choice when you’re feeding a crowd.
You can go classic with a New York-style cheese pizza, dig into a hearty deep-dish, keep it light with thin crust, or opt for one of their gourmet creations. They also offer a wide selection of toppings to mix and match so that you can build the perfect pizza.
My personal pick is their Butter Chicken Pizza. It’s loaded with juicy chicken pieces slow-cooked in a buttery, creamy sauce with just the right amount of spice.
For added savings, sign up for their email list or loyalty program, wherein you can score exclusive coupons and discounts every month.
| Pro Tip: If you’re hosting friends for a Friday night game, order their Flying Feast combo. It comes with two pizzas (three toppings each), 12 chicken wings, garlic breadsticks, and a 2L soft drink—the perfect spread for sharing while cheering on your team! |
Corrientes Argentine Pizzeria
– Media credit: corrienteswpg
Website: https://www.corrientes.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/corrienteswpg
Address: 137 Bannatyne Ave
Hours: Mon – Fri: 11:30 AM – 9 PM
Saturday: 12 PM – 10 PM
Sunday: 12 PM – 9 PM
Contact: (204) 219-5398
Must-Order: Steve B
Corrientes Argentine Pizzeria offers Latin American flavors, serving up empanadas, sandwiches, and of course, their signature pies. Named after Corrientes Avenue in Buenos Aires, they introduced Argentina’s famous thick-crust pizza.
Others might say no to peanut butter on their slice, but that’s only because they haven’t tried Steve B yet. This creative and delicious option combines tuco sauce, bacon, smoky Cajun chicken, mozzarella, cheddar, and crunchy peanut butter.
Vegans can swap in vegan cheese on any vegetarian flavors at no extra cost. That way, no one feels left out when the group order hits the table.
Keep an eye on their socials because they often host unique events, from Paint Nights to live Spanish music shows and fun tango classes.
| Pro Tip: A quick heads up for planners—on Fridays and Saturdays, table time limits may be in place for reservations. So, make sure to book ahead! |
Shorty’s Pizza
– Media credit: shortyspizza
Website: https://www.shortyspizza.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/shortyspizza/
Address: 53 Maryland St
Hours: Mon – Sun: 11:30 AM – 10 PM
Contact: (204) 779-7968
Must-Order: Tom Tom Club
Shorty’s Pizza has quickly become a neighborhood gem in Wolseley since opening in 2021. This fully licensed New York-style pizzeria focuses on what matters most: big, foldable slices and quality ingredients.
Their menu is said to be “ingredient-driven,” which means every topping and every slice is designed to shine. The dough itself is hand-stretched and rested for three days, creating the perfect chewy yet crispy texture.
One pie you can’t miss is their Tom Tom Club, a beauty that layers marinara with fior di latte, shredded mozzarella, heirloom tomatoes, and fiery Calabrian chilies. This flavor-packed combo hits all the notes—fresh, tangy, creamy, and spicy.
Vegans aren’t left out, either. They use cheese from the Vegan Fromagerie, a local maker that’s become a favorite for its amazing flavor and melt.
| Pro Tip: For seriously great deals, keep an eye on Shorty’s Instagram. You might score $6 slice-and-beer specials or pick up some fun, limited-edition merch. |
Santa Ana Pizzeria & Bistro
– Media credit: santaanapizzeria
Website: https://www.santaanabistro.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/santaanapizzeria
Address: 1631 St Mary’s Rd, Unit F
Hours: Tue – Sat: 9 AM – 8 PM
Contact: (204) 415-1440
Must-Order: Santa Ana
Santa Ana Pizzeria & Bistro might look unassuming, but it’s actually a go-to for gourmet pizzas. Bonus: they’re the only restaurant across Manitoba that uses Galbani Professionale low-fat pizza mozzarella—the number one premium cheese in Italy!
Their wood-fired pizzas are divine; they’re cooked at high heat to get that irresistible blistered crust with a rustic char and smoky flavor. My favorite is their signature Santa Ana, which comes topped with prosciutto di Parma, cauliflower, asparagus, and asiago.
As a bonus, they also serve stone-baked pizzas, which cook a little longer at a lower temperature. This is a perfect choice for those who want a crispier base and a more even bake all the way.
And since this is an Italian joint, pairing your pizza with wine is a must. White wine fans will love Sauvignon Blanc, Pinot Grigio, and Prosecco to complement light toppings, while red wine lovers can try their Shiraz, Chianti, Ripasso, and Amarone.
| Pro Tip: Santa Ana’s deals are hard to beat. Buy any 15” combination pizza for $38 and get the second for just $33, or pick up an 11” pizza for $24 and add a second for $20. |
The Pizza Oven
– Media credit: pizzaovenwinnipeg
Website: https://www.thepizzaoven.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/pizzaovenwinnipeg/
Address: 1215 Henderson Hwy
Hours: Mon – Thurs: 11 AM – 12 AM
Fri – Sat: 11 AM – 2 AM
Sunday: 11 AM – 11 PM
Contact: (204) 949-3000
Must-Order: The Pierogi Pie
If you can’t decide between a classic pie or a specialty one, then The Pizza Oven is the place for you. Both types are served here freshly made with quality ingredients, giving you a balance of homestyle comfort and big, bold flavors.
My top one here is their Pierogi Pie, which starts with a special sour cream sauce base. Then, it’s layered with Manitoba potatoes, smoked side bacon, green and red onions, and ranch dressing.
For those who like to take the reins, their Build Your Own Pizza option is a dream come true. You can make your pie as simple or as loaded as you’d like, with toppings such as shrimp, feta, jalapenos, banana peppers, and salami.
Come on a weekday to get extra savings! From Monday to Thursday, you can grab two 14” pizzas with two toppings each for just $26.99!
| Pro Tip: Don’t forget to sign up for their loyalty program—you’ll earn one point for every dollar you spend, and once you hit 50 points, that’s $1 off your next order. Collect 100 points, and you’ll unlock even more rewards! |
Pizzeria Gusto
– Media credit: pizzeriagusto
Website: https://pizzeriagusto.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/pizzeriagusto/
Address: 404 Academy Rd
Hours: Mon, Wed – Fri: 11:30 AM – 4 PM, 5 PM – 11 PM
Saturday: 5 PM – 11 PM
Contact: (204) 944-8786
Must-Order: Margherita
Pizzeria Gusto is a casual and buzzy spot with a secret weapon: their Valoriani wood-burning oven. It’s handcrafted in Tuscany by artisans who’ve been perfecting their craft for over five generations.
The Margherita here is superb—fresh, simple, and delicious, it’s made with San Marzano tomatoes, mozzarella di bufala, basil, and sea salt. You can elevate it with fun add-ons like a cracked egg on top or hot honey on the side.
Whenever I’m here, I pair my slice with their exclusive Italian Pilsner, the Good Neighbor Bene. It’s crisp and goes well with any of their wood-fired creations.
And when the weather’s warm, I always sit on their sun-soaked patio. It’s perfect for a long lunch, a romantic evening, or cocktails and pizza with friends.
| Pro Tip: Note that they can’t always guarantee a table for two, but don’t worry, their beautiful wine bar is designed for smaller groups. You and your friend or date can watch their bartenders mix, shake, and pour. |
Tony’s Master Of Pizza
– Media credit: bestpizzawinnipeg
Website: https://www.tonysmasterofpizza.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bestpizzawinnipeg/
Address: 1110b Pembina Hwy
Hours: Mon – Thurs, Sun: 11 AM – 10 PM
Fri – Sat: 11 AM – 11 PM
Contact: (204) 452-9797
Must-Order: Tony’s Special
Tony’s Master of Pizza has been a Winnipeg staple since 1972, serving up classic pies the old-school way. They’re dedicated to providing fresh, quality ingredients, from daily-prepped veggies to premium cheeses.
Every pizza here starts with a hand-rolled dough, cooked to perfection in their stone ovens. The result is a crust that bakes up golden-brown with just the right amount of chew—you can request it to be crispier or a little thicker, too.
Their signature sauce is another bonus. Made from scratch with a crushed tomato base, it’s left to rest for 24 hours before hitting the pizza, giving the flavors time to deepen.
As for my go-to order, that would be Tony’s Special. It’s their most popular pie, loaded with pepperoni, mushrooms, green pepper, and sausage.
| Pro Tip: Those obsessed with Tony’s scratch-made sauce are in luck. Ask for extra, and they’ll load you up at no extra charge! |